QUOTE(neothink @ May 28 2005, 12:39 PM)
The "intellectual puffery" and "intellectual superiority" of atheism? Say what? You're confusing intelligence with a failure to see the reality around you. It's amazing how clearly you can see the dangling carrot of afterlife through the fog and smoke yet you fail to see the reality of life.
your reality. you own that statement about dangling carrots and "the reality of life." i disowned atheism approximately 10 years ago for a stance that made sense of the absurdity i saw all around me and played out in the way people make the vast majority of their daily decisions based on fleeting subconscious impressions. i met people who suffered horribly, and i decided that the best comfort i could offer people who lived under the most permanently undesireable circumstances was "the carrot" your talking about. if i didn't think human life was so fundamentally absurd then maybe i'd still be a beer sloshing logical positivist.
QUOTE
Atheistic view "is trite and used up?" Interesting.
it is hackneyed. just as the christian apologetics are. wait a minute. i just called my posts hackneyed, didn't i? oh well, another ground hog day for me.
QUOTE
It's amazing how msyticism has advanced over the centuries. From the word of god, to. . .we don't take this and that litterally anymore to. . .what next? Is the next stage the whole thing is an allegory then what. . .a fairy tale?
nice oversimplification. imo, there is only one sane interpretation of christian teaching that is handed down from the apostles through all generations up to this present day. it is neatly but oversimply stated in the nicene creed.
QUOTE
Gogol, I'm willing to bet your "stimulating" life is one big "Groundhog Day" with "slight variations" just like the atheism v theism debate and just like this thread.
hey, no need to get personal. i thought we were discussing atheism and theism not the life of neothink and gogol.
QUOTE
We're all doomed. You just don't see it. . .or we are all saved. Mystics love to say that we are "given free will." What a joke. Seriously. God, as all mystics believe is omniEVERYTHING, therefore he knows exactly what you are going to do generations before you were born and he knows exactly what everyone is going to do generations from now. So, the "free will" is an enormous joke. Waste your time going after the dangling carrot, but it is all written and if it's all written then there can be no judgement because we had no say, since it was all known eons before our birth.[right][snapback]97491[/snapback][/right]
while i admit that free will is a hairy concept to wrestle with in the same conversation as an omniscient God, i think it's possible to see how God allows for human free and knows which ones will go bad from the beginning, eventhough it is not His
intention that they go bad. without going too "william f buckley " on you i would say that, in the same act of creating humans, God knew how all humans would be judged, but His will destining them to eternal damnation is not antecedent to but
consequent upon foreknowledge of their sin and their death in the state of sin. more simply, He had foreknowledge that some people would turn out bad based on their actual freely chosen path and as a consequence permitted them to be damned based on these demerits.
this is what the catholic cannon has to say about negative reprobation, and this is why it is Just for Christ to remark concerning judas, "It were better for him that he was never born" because Christ knew he would go bad from the beginning of time, that judas would be the one to betray him, just as he knows other people will not escape despair, or freely chosen separation from God/hope.